It’s 9 pm. The conversation ended hours ago. I’m folding laundry, or driving, or lying in bed trying to sleep, and there it is again.

Not the whole conversation. Just one part of it. The part where I said something a little too fast, or didn’t say something I should have, and now I am back there, editing it. Adding the smarter line. Cutting the awkward pause and building the version of me who sounded put together.

The moment is gone. I know that, and still I keep going back, as if I can somehow reach in and fix it from here.

For years, I thought this was my way of just being thoughtful. Too self-aware, a little conscientious. But eventually I realized I wasn’t reflecting anymore. I was looping. Reflection moves you somewhere. These circles were rumination.

Here’s what I’ve learned about my replays. It’s rarely about getting something wrong. It’s about what I left out. The smart thing I thought of two minutes too late. The comment that would have shown I was listening, or capable, or on top of things, and instead I said something forgettable, and the conversation moved on without me.

Honestly, it comes down to this: I want to be seen as dependable. Reliable. Someone who has it together. Someone smart enough that you’d remember what she said. And when I walk away from a conversation without leaving that impression, some part of me sits in judgment of myself for hours afterward.

That’s the real audition. Not the conversation itself. The performance review I give myself after, where I am both the woman on trial and the one deciding the verdict.

I used to think the fix was getting better at thinking on my feet. Being quicker. Sharper. Having the good line ready before the moment closed.

What actually changed things was almost the opposite.

I started listening more than I talked.

I noticed, somewhere in my forties, that the people I admired most weren’t the ones who said the most. They were the ones who made you feel seen and heard. And I realized I could not talk my way into being that person. I had to out-listen my way there.

If nothing else, my counseling program reminded me that the most important part of any conversation isn’t having the right response. It’s listening for what’s underneath the words. Once I started listening to others in this way, I realized I needed to begin doing so for myself.

Once you start listening that way, it’s hard to go back to just waiting for your turn to talk.

So now, when I have a thought mid-conversation, I don’t rush it out. I let it sit. Half the time, by the time there’s room for me to say it, it isn’t even the same thought anymore. It’s gone somewhere better. Deeper. And I am so glad, so many times, that I never said the first version out loud.

That’s the part nobody tells you about patience with your own thoughts. It’s not just about not interrupting other people. It’s about not interrupting yourself before your best thinking has finished arriving.

Subscribe now

I’ve grown into something else over the years, too. More grounded. More patient. Less rushed. I want to understand people now more than I want to respond to them. I can sit across from someone whose opinion I completely disagree with and still find the place where it makes sense to them, still hold some value in it, even if I never come around to it myself. That part of me has gotten generous.

I just haven’t figured out how to turn that same generosity toward myself.

My husband likes to point this out. He says I can repeat conversations from twenty years ago word for word. Not just the big ones. Random ones. A conversation with a stranger in a checkout line. It’s like the script just lives in my brain, filed away, ready to play back on demand. I am always scripting something, even when I don’t mean to be.

I still replay conversations sometimes. I’d be lying if I said this was fully behind me. But it happens less now, and when it does, I’ve got a question I ask myself that shortens the spiral considerably:

Am I actually worried I hurt someone?

Or… am I worried they didn’t leave impressed with me?

Most often, it’s the second one, and once I can see that clearly, it loses most of its grip. Because that’s not a wound. That is just my own fear of being ordinary, dressed up as concern for someone else.

These days, when I catch myself replaying a conversation, I pause. I ask myself one question. Am I worried I hurt someone… or am I worried they weren’t impressed by me?

I ground myself in the present. I remind myself that whatever is happening right now, in this room, is real and that the conversation from three hours ago is not.

And then I do something physical to help my body catch up with that decision, because deciding to let it go and actually feeling let go of it are two different things. I go for a walk, move my body, and try to move with intention. I listen to music and make a cup of coffee. I take a few deep breaths, or I pick up a book and let my mind go somewhere else entirely. It doesn’t matter which one I chose. What matters is that I stop trying to think my way out of it and give my body something to do instead.

The conversation is over. It ended the second it ended. There is no version of tonight where I climb back into it and deliver the better line.

But there is a version of tomorrow where I trust that who I am isn’t determined by one conversation.

Maybe that’s what I’m really practicing.

Not saying the perfect thing. Believing that I don’t have to.

I wasn’t overthinking.

I was auditioning for a role I already have.

Still becoming. 🌊

Subscribe now

My son Michael is 18 years old. He is an Eagle Scout. He reads everything. He has kept the same tight circle of friends since elementary school, and he would do anything for them. At the end of the day, he still tucks himself under my arm on the couch, all five feet eight inches and 160 pounds of him—and waits for me to rub his feet. He has done this since he was small. I do not think he will ever stop, and honestly, I hope he never does.

Michael moves through life at his own pace. Slowly. Deliberately. He has an internal compass that has absolutely nothing to do with what anyone else thinks he should be doing or how fast he should do it. My husband Bob and I have a saying about Michael that we often repeat to each other, sometimes with frustration and always with love: he is the laziest smart person we have ever met.

There is no hustle in him. No urgency. No sense that the clock is ticking and he needs to move faster. Getting him out of the house in the morning is a major project. The shower situation alone could fill a whole chapter.

And yet, to know Michael is to love him. Underneath the slowness, the quiet, and the complete indifference to other people’s timelines, there is a person of extraordinary depth. He feels everything. He notices everything. He carries far more than he ever shows.

I want to be honest here, because I am not a naive parent. I am not writing this to defend a perfect kid. Michael can be genuinely frustrating to coach. He is extremely quiet. He rarely communicates to his coach that he has actually heard the feedback. He does not rush. He refuses to perform an urgency he does not feel.

There are two coaches on his tennis team, and the head coach has a completely different approach. This essay is about the assistant coach.

My husband and I are not new to sports parenting. Our daughter, Lily, played three varsity sports each year of high school and was a consistent starter. We have spent years sitting on the sidelines and freezing in bleachers. We know exactly what good coaching looks like. This assistant coach coached Lily in basketball, so we have watched him use these same tactics before. He talks about the kids behind their backs. He focuses almost entirely on winning. He rarely operates from a place of genuine investment in the person standing in front of him. We know exactly what we are watching.

Michael did not even pick up a racket until his sophomore year of high school. Most of the kids he competed against had been playing for years. Yet, Michael attended tennis camp twice a week all summer, playing challenge match after challenge match to earn his varsity spot. He did all of that slowly, in the exact way Michael does everything—and he earned a second-doubles varsity position. He shows up to every single practice and works hard in his own distinct way. It does not always look like what other people expect, but it is consistent and real.

Subscribe now

Last week, Michael played a match that stretched past the two-hour mark. His partner was struggling with knee pain, unable to play at his usual level. Michael quietly stepped up, carrying most of the weight of the match. They won the first two sets, but by the third, things began to fall apart. The opposing team mounted a comeback, pushing the match into a grueling tiebreaker.

The assistant coach was standing nearby. From where I was standing, I could see him clearly. He was mocking Michael. He was literally imitating the way my son moves, muttering comments under his breath that he assumed Michael couldn’t hear.

But Michael heard every single word.

He didn’t tell me until we were sitting at the dinner table later that night. He heard everything, because Michael always does. He said almost nothing on the court in that moment—because that is just who he is; he processes deeply and responds deliberately, but it all registered. He told me how awful he felt for his partner, because the coach was also muttering about the boy, claiming he was “always whining” and that “everything always hurts him.”

Michael wasn’t just playing a two-hour tiebreaker; he was carrying the heavy emotional weight of two teenagers on his shoulders.

Then he told me the part that stopped me completely. He looked at me and said he felt like losing on purpose. Not because he didn’t care about winning. Michael loves to win. He wants to win for himself and for his team, many of whom are his closest friends. This is not a kid lacking competitive drive. But the coach’s cruel tactics had tainted the experience and robbed the meaning from the game. It made performing for that man feel pointless. Worse than pointless—it made losing feel like the only quiet rebellion that made sense.

He didn’t lose on purpose. He would never do that. Not because of the coach, but because of his partner and his teammates. Because Michael is the kind of person who will push through almost anything for someone he actually loves. The coach did not keep him in that match. His teammate did. Think about what that means for a moment.

And this week, the week after that match, Michael was named athlete of the week.

As a school psychologist and aspiring mental health clinician, I understand where this coaching philosophy comes from. It is old. It is deeply woven into sports culture. Shame them a little. Make them uncomfortable. Put a fire under them. Make them want to prove you wrong.

For some kids, in some contexts, with a coach they already trust and feel respected by, a well-timed challenge can work. I will give the old school that much. But the research is clear about what shame-based coaching actually does to most kids. Studies show that when we tie an athlete’s self-worth to their performance, introducing shame doesn't motivate them—it actively drives anxiety and burnout. It heaps on psychological stress while quietly stripping away any real sense of personal accomplishment.

On the flip side, the science shows exactly what happens when coaches choose respect over ridicule. Studies call this 'autonomy-supportive' coaching, but it really just means building an environment on encouragement, honest communication, and basic human dignity. When kids get that, they develop real resilience and a deep, lasting optimism. Shame doesn’t build athletes. The data tells us this unequivocally

But here is what clinical research cannot fully capture, and a career of sitting across from children has taught me directly: every single child is wired differently.

My daughter, Lily, would be mortified if a coach embarrassed her publicly. But she would channel every single bit of that mortification into something fierce. She would come back harder. For her, a specific type of abrasive challenge serves as fuel.

Michael is built completely differently. He is deeply empathetic. He feels his own experience and everyone else’s at the same time. He processes quietly, completely, and keeps most of the internal storm hidden from view. Since the first grade, he has always needed to know that his teachers genuinely liked him. Not a performance of care, they had to actually mean it. Once he knew a teacher truly cared about him, he would do absolutely anything for them. He would work harder than anyone expected and show up in ways that surprised everyone.

Without that authentic relationship? He gives back exactly what he receives.

The coach gave him mockery. Michael gave him silence, alongside the quiet, rational thought that losing might actually feel better than performing for someone who did not respect him. That isn’t a lack of drive. It is a highly intuitive nervous system doing exactly what it was built to do: protect itself from an attack.

I am not arguing for soft coaching. I am not saying athletes should never be pushed, challenged, or asked to do more than they believe they are capable of achieving. I am saying that the challenge must come from a baseline of a relationship. It has to come from a coach who has taken the time to understand how each athlete is wired. It must arrive with the athlete’s dignity entirely intact. Without that foundation, the challenge does not land as motivation. It lands as an emotional attack.

We are no longer living in a world where one-size-fits-all coaching is acceptable. Kids today know when an emotional line has been crossed. They possess the language for it. They have self-awareness. They know when someone does not actually respect them, even when that person is standing on the same court wearing the school colors.

Michael knew. He heard every word. He said nothing. He went out and carried a grueling, two-hour tiebreaker for his team—not for his coach, but for his friends. Then he came home, ate dinner, and told his mother what happened.

And his mother happens to have 30 years of experience working with kids, a counseling degree in progress, and a Substack. So, she wrote it down.

My son earned athlete of the week this week. He did that for himself. For his partner. For his friends who were cheering from the sidelines. He did not do it for the coach who mocked him from the sidelines.

That should tell us everything we need to know.

Leave a comment

There is a puzzle on the dining room table at my house. It has been there for years in my mind — not a real puzzle, but the image I keep coming back to when I try to explain what empty nest actually feels like. Picture a thousand pieces. All of them in place. The edges complete, the middle filled in, every color exactly where it belongs. A finished thing. A whole thing. Except for one piece. Small. Right in the center. Right over your heart. That piece is missing. And no matter how beautiful the rest of the puzzle looks, your eye goes there every time. That is empty nest.

Not a breakdown. Not a crisis. Just a quiet, persistent awareness that something that belongs there isn’t there anymore.

I should be clear about one thing: Michael is still here. He is eighteen and wonderfully, quietly independent in the way teenage boys often are. He is home. He is fed. He is fine. But if you have a daughter, you already know what I mean when I say her absence hits differently. Lily and I talked constantly. We went for coffee and chatted endlessly. We had rhythms and rituals that belonged exclusively to us. When she left, those things did not transfer to anyone else. They just stopped.

Michael will leave next year. I already feel the anxiety creeping in at the edges, the way mothers hold things they are not ready to claim just yet.

But that is its own essay for another day.

This one is about what happened when she left.

THE BAD

For months after Lily left for college, I drove past her restaurant.

She had worked there every summer since middle school. It was her place. Every single time I passed it, my brain lied to me and said she was inside. I could see her with her apron on, her section full, probably making everyone laugh. Then the reality would hit. She was six hours away at school, and I was pulling over on my way to work, on the verge of a breakdown.

The first year felt exactly like losing your keys. You walk from room to room, retracing your steps, certain the answer is right in front of you if you could just remember. Except I wasn’t looking for my keys. I was looking for her. My brain kept running the search script even though I knew her exact coordinates. It just couldn’t stop checking.

Nobody warns you about the forgetting.

I don’t mean the big, dramatic grief you can name and explain to a friend. I mean the low-grade anxiety that shadows you from room to room, whispering that you left something important behind, but you can’t remember what. Except the thing you forgot is a person. A whole human being who used to fill your house with noise, need, and life.

Some nights, I did more than just glance down the dark hallway. I went in. I sat on her bed and sobbed like a baby. When the tears finally stopped, I would just sit there in the dark. Not sad, exactly. Just remembering. I replayed her whole life like an old film reel—the kitchen scenes, the car rides, the sports, the recitals, the late-night chats. How did we get here? How is she already this grown? I desperately missed my little girl with the pixie haircut and the bony arms wrapped tight around my neck, her raspy little voice saying “mommy” like it was the easiest word in the world.

A few of those nights, I didn’t leave. I slept in her bed, wrapped tight in her white comforter because it still held her scent—a mix of perfume, laundry detergent, and that underlying skin-smell that was just her. I am not embarrassed to tell you that. I needed to be close to something that still held her shape.

Sleep was the hardest part. I am someone who needs her people accounted for before my eyes can close. Always have been. For almost twenty years, my people were down the hall. Now, suddenly, one of them was entirely out of reach in the way that lets a mother’s nervous system finally exhale.

My sleep fell apart for a while. Not dramatically. Just quietly, the way things fall apart when nobody is watching.

The holidays brought their own particular ache. The school breaks we used to spend together—just the two of us running pointless errands, seeing a movie, or doing absolutely nothing. The birthdays that suddenly required a calendar conversation instead of just showing up with a cake. And the hardest part of all: watching the new high school senior class go through their rituals, knowing I was quietly reliving Lily’s final year in my head the entire time. It went too fast. I just wanted it to be longer. I kept asking the walls how we got here already.

I think about my own mother sometimes. She raised me in a world without iPhones, FaceTime, or the ability to pop open a screen at any hour to see my face. I get to see Lily whenever I want. My mother didn’t have that luxury. She did this entirely in the dark, never knowing for certain how I was doing in any given moment. I have endless access compared to her, and I still found it this agonizing. I honestly don’t know how she survived it.

The Ugly

Here is the part I was not sure I should write.

About six months after Lily left, I noticed something I did not expect—and something I was not prepared to feel good about.

I liked the quiet.

Not at first. At first, the silence was unbearable. But somewhere around month six, I started to settle into it. I started working out consistently for the first time in years. Bob and I started having actual date nights—not rushed dinners crammed between sports drop-offs and activity pickups, but real evenings where we sat across from each other and remembered who we were before we became managers of a household. I had lazy Sunday mornings. I read books. I took long walks with Nash without checking my watch. I stopped putting myself at the very bottom of the priority list.

And then came the guilt.

Women are not supposed to admit this. We are programmed from the beginning—biologically and socially, to be attuned to our children above everything else. You could be fast asleep, and if your child whispers from two rooms away, you are awake before your brain even registers why. That attunement is real. It keeps them alive. It is also, eventually, exhausting in ways we are never allowed to say out loud.

Who do we think we are, wanting something for ourselves?

Who do we think we are, craving time, quiet, and a life that has our own name on it?

I will tell you who we are. We are women. We are full human beings with interior lives, needs, desires, and second chapters that do not require anyone’s permission. We have spent so long rationalizing ourselves into smaller and smaller corners, meeting everyone else’s needs first, last, and in between—that wanting more feels like a betrayal.

It is not a betrayal. It is becoming.

But nobody tells you that. So you enjoy the quiet, feel guilty about the quiet, and then feel guilty about feeling guilty. It is exhausting in a completely different way.

Subscribe now

THE GOOD

Lily came home last month, and we went to dinner. Just the two of us. We sat at a corner table for three hours and talked the way I have always wanted to talk with her. We weren’t mother and daughter navigating the logistics of a shared house anymore; we were two women who genuinely liked each other’s company. She told me things about her life I never would have heard before. I told her things about mine. We laughed until we were both crying over something I will never repeat here, because it belongs entirely to us.

That is the gift nobody told me about. When she chooses to be with me now, it means something entirely new. She isn’t there because I made her dinner or because I am her ride. She is there because she wants to be. I receive her presence differently than I ever could when she lived down the hall.

When she comes home, the atmosphere of the whole house shifts. I sleep the way I slept when my children were tiny—deeply, completely, the way you sleep when all your people are accounted for, the nest is full, and everything is exactly where it belongs. My head hits the pillow, and I feel a calm that is almost cellular. All is right with the world.

And then, when she leaves again, the quiet settles back in—and I exhale into it.

Both things are true. I hold both things at once. That is not a contradiction. That is just motherhood in the second chapter.

THE PART NOBODY TELLS YOU

Here is the thing I did not expect. Empty nest is not one single goodbye. It is the exact same heartbreak, over and over, every single time she leaves again.

She comes home for Christmas or summer break, and the house fills right back up with her chaos. The shoes appear in the entryway, the laughter bounces off the kitchen walls, and I sleep deeply again—the way I slept when she was tiny.

Then the suitcases come back out. The car pulls away. She leaves again, and it hits exactly as hard as the first time.

You would think it gets easier. You tell yourself you have done this before. You knew it was coming. You already survived it once. It does not matter. The grief does not care about your experience. It shows up raw every single time, like it has something to prove.

Then the anger sets in. You blame yourself for being caught off guard. You knew this was coming. You should be better at this by now.

But here is what I know to be true as a school psychologist: you are not failing at grief. Every single reunion reactivates the attachment. Every single goodbye re-triggers the loss. That is not a sign of weakness. That is simply how love behaves inside a nervous system that has nowhere else to put it.

There is a particular kind of ache that comes with watching your daughter become exactly who she was always meant to be.

I am so proud of her I could cry, and some days I do. Lily is brave. She is incredibly smart, driven, and the hardest worker I know. She says yes to adventures I would have been too terrified to try at her age. She is becoming her own woman in real time, right in front of me. I did my job. She is flying. She is soaring. That is precisely what she is supposed to do, and I want all of it for her. She needs all of it. My heart is genuinely, completely happy for her.

And still.

Some days I just want her to be seven years old again. I want the pixie haircut, the bony little arms wrapped tight around my neck, and that raspy little voice saying “mommy” like it was the only word she would ever need. I want her to rub my eyebrow the way she used to when she couldn’t fall asleep.

Both things are true at once. The pride and the grief live in the same chest, on the same day, sometimes in the exact same hour. Nobody tells you that motherhood asks you to hold both forever. They don’t tell you that you can be absolutely thrilled for the woman she is becoming, and simultaneously devastated for the little girl she no longer is. It is not a contradiction. It is not confusion.

That is just what loving someone across time feels like.

I am in a much more peaceful place now.

Those first couple of years were a heavy, overwhelming fog. But time and distance have taught me how to carry both feelings without letting either one cancel the other out. Time moves too fast. It always did. Nobody warns you how fast until you are standing in the middle of the wreckage, so incredibly grateful and so completely undone.

I AM BARBARA

I will be a mother every day for the rest of my life. I will always be Lily’s mother and Michael’s mother. I will never stop being attuned to them in that particular, instinctual way that only mothers understand.

But I am also Barbara.

I am vibrant. I am interesting, and I am interested. I am a school psychologist with twenty-five years of experience watching human beings survive seemingly impossible things. I am a graduate student at fifty-three, sitting in classrooms and learning things I thought I had missed out on forever. I am a writer. I am a woman who walks to the bay every single evening, watching the light change over the open water, feeling something deep that I do not always have the words for.

I am evolving. And I refuse to apologize for that.

I refuse to ration myself out in tiny pieces just to meet a traditional definition of what a midlife mother is supposed to want. I refuse to shrink myself so that my growth feels less threatening to a world that has never quite known what to do with a woman who insists on continuing.

The empty nest cracked something open inside of me. The bad was entirely real. The ugly was real. But the good—the unexpected, unearned, beautiful good—was more than I ever knew how to hope for.

The puzzle on the table still has that one piece missing right in the center. It probably always will. But the rest of the picture is more complete than it has ever been.

Subscribe now

Leave a comment

Subscribe now

The heavy fog of anesthesia began to lift, leaving me in that hazy, fuzzy world between sleep and waking. Before I even opened my eyes, I felt her.

It wasn’t a passing thought or a sudden memory. It was a physical presence. Mom was standing right beside my hospital bed, leaning in with that exact, unmistakable look she always gave me when she was worried—the expression that relayed I am right here without making a sound. The illusion was flawless. I could even feel the precise vibration in the air right before she was about to tell me everything would be fine.

Then, the fog cleared.

My eyes blinked open to the harsh, blinding brightness of a recovery room. The space beside my bed was empty. My mother had been gone for five years. As the quiet, heavy kind of sadness settled over me, I stared at the ceiling and asked myself a frustrating question: Why does my brain keep doing this to me?

I am not a stranger to the mechanics of the mind. I have spent 25 years working as a school psychologist, and I am currently a graduate student in clinical mental health counseling. I have spent my entire adult life studying how humans process emotion. I know the theoretical frameworks of grief inside and out. I have sat with families during the absolute worst moments of their lives, helping them map out and make sense of their pain.

And yet, there I was. Destabilized by my own mind, which was still desperately searching for a ghost.

It felt like a failure of my training until I looked deeper. It turns out, there is a precise, beautiful neurological reason why our brains do this—and discovering it completely changed how I carry my own grief.

—

What Your Brain Actually Does When It Loves Someone

Neuroscience studies have established something profound about human attachment. When we form deep bonds with another person over time, the brain does not simply store memories of them. It builds a predictive model — a living internal representation that anticipates their presence, their responses, their location in your world.

Research published in Biological Psychiatry: Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuroimaging proposes what researchers call the gone-but-also-everlasting model of grief — a framework combining human and animal neuroscience with attachment theory. The model posits that after a loss, two competing systems operate simultaneously inside the grieving brain. One holds the factual knowledge that the person is gone. The other continues running the internal model it spent years building — still generating predictions, still sending the signal, still waiting for them to appear.

This is what happened in that recovery room. My nervous system had learned, across 49 years, that when I was sick or scared or vulnerable, my mother appeared. It was predicting what it had always known to be true. And then reality corrected it.

That correction is grief.

This isn’t a disease or a failure to cope. It is the hard collision between what the brain was built to expect and what the world actually gives you. The brain’s internal map does not automatically update the moment someone dies. It has to relearn the entire world without them. Science informs us that this rewriting process takes time, real-world experience, and a deep physical reorganization of the brain itself.

This is the reason grief does not follow a timeline. It follows the brain's own pace of relearning. And that pace is far slower and far more nonlinear than anyone tells you when you lose someone.

—

Why She Finds You When You Are Not Looking

The neuroscience of grief is not only about absence. There is another phenomenon happening simultaneously, and it is equally important to understand.

Sometimes Mom shows up at the most unexpected times. It takes so little. The smell of coffee brewing in the morning. Sunday gravy simmering on the stove. A specific song on the radio when the light outside looks a certain way and the breeze has that distinct autumn chill. Suddenly, I am not in my car in 2025. I am back. Completely, involuntarily, and without warning.

This is not imagination. This is your brain doing something remarkable that neuroscientists have studied for over a century.

Research published in Chemical Senses confirms that smell is neurologically unique among human senses. It is the only sensory pathway that bypasses the thalamus entirely. Sight, sound, touch, and taste must all travel first through this central relay station before reaching the cortex. Smell, however, takes a direct route to the amygdala, which processes emotion, and the hippocampus, which forms long-term memories.

Subscribe now

The physical reality of this anatomy changes everything. A smell does not just bring up a memory of someone. It instantly restarts the exact emotion you felt when you first shared that scent with them. It drops you right back into the feeling, not just the hard facts.

The smell of that gravy does not simply make me remember my mother cooking a Sunday meal. It physically drags me back into her kitchen. I feel the safety, the warmth of being fed, and the unmistakable comfort of being her daughter in a house that smelled exactly like that.

A 2023 study published in Current Opinion in Psychology confirms this exact phenomenon, known as the Proust Effect. Researchers found that memories triggered by smell are deeply personal, exceptionally vivid, and carry a far stronger emotional punch than memories sparked by any other sense. People in these studies consistently report that a scent-evoked memory doesn't feel like a simple act of remembering. Instead, it feels like actually returning to that exact moment in time.

The effect multiplies when multiple sensory signals arrive at the same time—smell, sound, and light. The brain receives a cluster of cues that all point to the exact same memory. Because of this, the mental picture it rebuilds is more complete, more overwhelming, and more real.

This is not your grief spiraling out of control. This is your nervous system doing something extraordinary. It preserved her. It stored her so deeply that years after she is gone, a simple combination of everyday sights, sounds, and smells can bring her back to you almost completely.

Why Certain Days Hit Harder Than Others

A 2025 narrative review by Statharakos in Brain Science Advances confirms that grief is not just a psychological state. Grief is a physical, and biological event. When you grieve, hormones like cortisol and oxytocin spin out of balance, changing how your body functions. At the same time, the brain regions that handle memory, attachment, and emotion physically alter. Your grief lives in your body, your hormones, and the very neural wiring you built around that relationship.

This is why anniversaries and holidays hit so hard. They act as massive, combined triggers. Mother’s Day isn’t just a date on the calendar. It is a day when every commercial, flower shop window, and social media post forces your brain to run a prediction it has practiced for decades:

She should be here.

This is the day for her.

Find her.

But the brain does not find her. Every time this prediction fails, your mind has to absorb and process a painful correction.

A 2024 paper from Oxford Academic’s Neuroscience of Consciousness makes an important point: grief is not a quick, isolated mood that comes and goes. It is a massive, winding process that reshapes itself over time through everything you experience. This science directly contradicts the cultural pressure to heal on a neat, predictable timeline.

The brain does not grieve on a schedule. It mends through its own deeply personal, messy rewiring—completely ignoring the expectations of anyone who doesn’t understand the physical work your biology is doing.

What I Want You to Know

I write here because I believe midlife women deserve clinically accurate facts about their own minds—not just emotional comfort, but real science that explains what they are living through.

So let me be completely direct with you.

You are not broken for still missing her years later. Being ambushed by a smell in the grocery store is not a sign of weakness. You are not failing because your grief has not cleared up on the neat timeline people expected.

These experiences have a name and a physical mechanism. They are documented in peer-reviewed neurological research published in respected scientific journals.

For decades, your mind mapped out a life with your loved one. When they die, that map is not instantly deleted. Instead, through time and experience, your brain gradually learns to hold that map differently. It learns to love the memory of what was, without expecting to ever arrive there again.

That is grief.

The fact that your brain is still working through it—still reaching for her in recovery rooms, still finding her in coffee, gravy, and autumn light—is not evidence of weakness.

It is proof of how completely she was woven into you.

That is not something to fix.

That is something to understand.

— Barb

Share

Clinical References

Statharakos, N. (2025). Unraveling the neurobiology of grief: Insights into brain and behavior — narrative review. Brain Science Advances. https://doi.org/10.26599/BSA.2025.905001

Kakarala, S.E., et al. (2020). The neurobiological reward system in prolonged grief disorder (PGD): A systematic review. Psychiatry Research: Neuroimaging, 303, 111135. Biological Psychiatry: Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuroimaging.

Ratcliffe, M., & Fernandez Velasco, P. (2024). The nature of grief: Implications for the neurobiology of emotion. Neuroscience of Consciousness. Oxford Academic. https://doi.org/10.1093/nc/niae041

Green, J.D., Reid, C.A., Wildschut, T., & Sedikides, C. (2023). The Proust effect: Scents, food, and nostalgia. Current Opinion in Psychology, 50, 101562. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.copsyc.2023.101562

El Haj, M., et al. (2018). From nose to memory: The involuntary nature of odor-evoked autobiographical memories. Chemical Senses, 43(1), 27-34. Oxford Academic. https://doi.org/10.1093/chemse/bjx075

Leave a comment

Share Barb | The Midlife Becoming

Subscribe now

My mother had a massive stroke in 2012 when my daughter Lily was about nine years old.

From that moment forward, my life divided itself into two clear categories: everything that needed to be done, and everything that would have to wait. My mother’s health deteriorated, and she moved into a nursing home and then into assisted living. My kids were growing up fast and needed everything I had. My husband Bob was steady beside me, as he always has been. My job as a school psychologist required everything that was left.

I gave it all willingly. This is simply who I am.

Caring for a mother with advancing dementia is its own kind of long goodbye. I lived inside that goodbye for nearly a decade. In 2018, her doctors diagnosed her with stage four kidney disease, and she started dialysis treatment. Three months of it. Every single day, I drove her to the dialysis center and sat beside her in the cold sterile bay. I held her hand while she pulled at the tubes. Her dementia was so advanced by then that she couldn’t understand why they were there. I would hold her hands gently, talk to her, watch the clock, and think about everything I still needed to do before the day was over.

Mom hated every minute of it. She had told us clearly, that she did not want to be kept alive by machines. She tried dialysis for us. Because we loved her and we were not ready to say goodbye. But eventually we stopped, because she had asked us to, and because love sometimes means listening even when it breaks you.

Then COVID came and locked the doors.

For months, we could not go inside at all. When visits were permitted, we sat on the terrace outside while she came to the glass, masked and gowned and separated by more than distance. All the ordinary moments I hadn’t thought to protect; sitting beside her, holding her hand without gloves, being in the same room with the easy assumption of more time — I didn’t know until they were gone how much they had been holding me up.

We finally got back inside. Two months later, in March of 2021, she was gone.

I was 48 years old and parentless for the first time in my life.

Subscribe now

Grief is strange. It does not arrive the way you expect it to.

What arrived for me, somewhere in the weeks and months after my mother passed, was not emptiness exactly. It was something quieter and harder to name. A kind of stirring. A force I can only describe as her — her spirit, her goodness, the energy of a woman who spent her whole life pouring herself into other people, settling into me and pushing me forward.

I cannot explain it theologically or clinically. I can only tell you that after she died, I felt, more powerfully than I ever had before, that I needed to do something with whatever time I had left. That life was shorter than I had been living like it was. That I had gifts, and energy, and a heart full of desire to help people, and I was not using them as fully as I could.

So, I started praying.

Not a complicated prayer. Not a long one. Just three words, said in the car and at the end of long days and in the quiet moments before sleep.

God, use me.

I wanted to be impactful. I wanted to reach people. I wanted to put good into the world in whatever way I could, for as long as I had to do it, in honor of a woman who had done exactly that her entire life.

I joined the county traumatic loss coalition and started responding to school tragedies. I became involved in the women’s commission. I started to say yes to things that scared me a little. I kept showing up in rooms where I could be useful to someone who needed it.

And I went back to school.

I had wanted to be a licensed psychologist since I was ten years old. The school psychology career gave me 25 years of meaningful work, but it kept me inside a building and a system with walls I could feel. I needed the clinical license to reach people outside those walls, outside the hours between eight and three, outside every limitation that had kept my calling contained.

So at 50, I enrolled in William and Mary’s clinical mental health counseling program. With a full-time job and a family and a life already packed to the edges, I went back to school. I learned Canvas and APA format and what an em dash is. I sat in class with people my daughter’s age, and they kept me honest and occasionally helped me find the submit button.

That was 2023. I kept praying.

God, use me.

Then on February 10th, 2025, I had unexpected knee surgery.

A full meniscus repair. Requiring months of non-weight-bearing. A brace on my leg, crutches beside the couch, ice packs around the clock. For the first time in my adult life, I was forced to stop completely. Not just slow down. Not rest when I could find a moment. Stop. Against every instinct I have ever had.

I read six books. I watched five movies. And then I was, as I told Bob, bored completely out of my ever-loving mind.

I started watching YouTube videos about content creation, social media, and how to build something on the internet. I watched for days. I read everything I could find. I had no plan, no strategy, and no expectation of anything specific happening.

And then seven days after surgery, on February 17th, something came over me like a tidal wave.

I clicked a button and launched @themidlifebecoming on Instagram.

With no grand design. No roadmap. Just a prayer that had been building since March of 2021 and a couch and a brace and a Tuesday with nowhere else to be.

Two months later, on April 18th, I launched Midlife Becoming on Substack. Because I had so many words inside me that Instagram could not hold them all. The writing — the long, honest, personal kind was where everything I had been carrying finally had room to breathe. Eighteen days after that, I had 100 subscribers.

Women from New Jersey, Australia, and South Africa and everywhere in between found their way to something I built on a coach and said — yes. “Me too”. I needed this.

A woman wrote to me about caring for her aging mother alone. Another wrote about the grief of losing herself inside a life that had stopped fitting years ago. Another wrote at what must have been two in the morning about the exhaustion of performing a version of herself that had never really been hers.

And I sat there, leg still elevated, still on crutches, reading their words, and I thought:

There it is. That is the answer.

Not in a school building after a tragedy. Not in a coalition meeting. Not in a clinical office with a license on the wall, which I am still working toward and will have.

On a couch. On the internet. I was reaching women I have never met who needed someone to tell them — you are not alone in this. You are not too late. You are not done yet.

My mother spent her whole life pouring herself into other people. She cooked for everyone. She showed up for everyone. She loved without reservation and without keeping score.

She never got to see what I built.

But I believe she knows.

I believe she is part of why the tidal wave came when it did, why the words arrived faster than I could write them down, why 100 women found a page I created on a couch in seven days and said — this is exactly what I needed.

She always wanted to help people, too.

Maybe this is both of us finally getting the chance.

The prayer was never asking God to make me important.

It was asking God to make me useful.

He answered it. Just not the way I expected.

But then — He never does.

The best answers never come the way you plan for them. They come on a Tuesday in February when you are stuck on a couch with your leg in a brace, a YouTube video playing, and absolutely nowhere else to be.

That is when the tidal wave finds you.

That is when you finally have room to let it.

Subscribe now

Leave a comment

I see you.

Not the version that has it together. Not the one who shows up looking fine, saying she is fine, moving through her days with the practiced efficiency of someone who learned a long time ago that falling apart is not an option she can afford.

The other one.

The one underneath all of that.

The one who lies awake sometimes and thinks, what if I just started. What if I actually did the thing I keep almost doing? What if this is not too late, and I am not too old, and the window has not actually closed on me the way I keep telling myself it has.

I know her.

I have been her.

I want to talk to her today.

Subscribe now

***

Here is what I need you to understand about fear.

It does not mean stop. It never meant stop.

Fear is your nervous system doing its job, scanning the horizon, flagging the unknown, trying to protect you from everything that has not happened yet. It is not wisdom. It is not a verdict on your readiness or your worth or whether this thing you want is meant for someone like you.

It is biology. And it has been keeping midlife women small for a very long time by disguising itself as something reasonable.

I am not ready yet.

I need to know more first.

Someone else is already doing this better than I ever could.

Who am I to think I have something worth saying?

I have thought every one of those things. Some of them on the same Tuesday afternoon.

And then on February 17th, 2025, seven days after knee surgery, sitting on a couch with my leg in a cast and a YouTube video playing, I clicked a button and started anyway.

Not because I was ready. Not because the fear had gone quiet. Not because I had a plan or a strategy or any guarantee that anyone would care.

Because staying where I was had finally cost more than moving forward scared.

***

That is the thing nobody tells you about beginning.

You do not wait until you feel ready. Ready is a story fear tells you to keep you exactly where you are.

You begin in the middle of the fear. Shaking hands. Racing heart. The voice in your head asking, “who do you think you are?” You begin anyway, and then you put your phone face down because you cannot stand to watch.

And then something happens that you did not see coming.

Someone finds you.

Someone reads what you wrote or hears what you said and thinks — that is exactly me. I have never heard anyone say that out loud before. How did she know?

That first “me too” changes everything. Because now you are not just making something for yourself. You are making something for her. And her. And the woman in Australia and the woman in South Africa and the woman three towns over who has been carrying the same quiet thing and needed someone to name it first.

You cannot get to her without beginning scared.

There is no other door in.

***

So I want to ask you something directly.

What is the thing you keep almost starting? —

Not the responsible answer. The real one. The one that surfaces at 2 AM and gets buried again by morning because it feels too big or too late or too much like something that belongs to a different kind of woman than you.

What is it? The writing. The business. The pivot. The platform. The conversation you have been rehearsing in your head for two years. Whatever it is.

Because I need you to hear something.

You are exactly the right kind of woman.

You have 45 or 52 or 58 years of living and surviving and becoming behind you. That is not a liability. That is the whole point. The thing you are scared to begin — it needs everything you have already lived to be what it is supposed to be.

Nobody younger can do what you can do with this.

Nobody with less scar tissue and less hard-won knowing and less of the specific wisdom that comes from having been through the things you have been through.

You are not behind.

You are exactly on time.

***

Begin this week.

Not perfectly. Not with a finished plan. Not when you feel ready, because that feeling is not coming the way you are waiting for it.

Begin the way I did. Scared. Sitting somewhere unexpected. No guarantee of anything except that staying where you were is no longer something your heart will accept.

The fear does not disappear when you start.

But something else arrives alongside it.

Something that feels a lot like finally.

With love from the Jersey Shore, — Barb

Midlife Becoming — for women who aren’t done yet. Subscribe at midlifebecoming.substack.com — always free, always honest.

I became a school psychologist because I wanted to work with children. I wanted to do the quiet work. The real work. The kind that happens when a kid finally feels safe enough to tell you the thing they have never told anyone. What I did not anticipate was everything else.

The paperwork, the documentation, and the scheduling. The meetings that fill the calendar so completely that some weeks the actual children, the reason I walked into this building in the first place, feel like a footnote in my own job description.

School psychologists, counselors, and learning consultants are what I have come to think of as the invisible infrastructure of a school district. We are rarely in the headlines. We do not receive the recognition that teachers receive or the authority that administrators hold. We move quietly through the building, tending to the things nobody wants to look at directly.

Feeding families who have no food.

Navigating housing crises that show up as a child’s inability to concentrate in the third period.

Sitting with the scars that children carry through the front door every single morning, five days a week, ten months a year, year after year.

We see everything.

Here is what almost 25 years of seeing everything has taught me.

Children are the most resilient beings I have ever encountered.

Not in the inspirational sense. In the raw, contradictory, sometimes heartbreaking sense that stops you cold and makes you wonder how a human being this small is still standing.

I started in drug and alcohol counseling right out of college. Then, at 24, I became a child protective services worker.

At 24. I walked into homes that no one should have to walk into and sat across from children who had experienced things I could not have imagined before I took that job. I made decisions that affected families permanently. I carried case files home in my mind every single night because there was no way not to.

What I saw in those children, over and over, in the worst circumstances imaginable, was the same thing I have been seeing ever since.

They showed up anyway.

Not because their lives were okay. Not because anyone made it easy. But because something in a child reaches toward survival, connection, and the possibility of better, with a stubbornness that humbles me every single time I witness it.

Child Protective Services taught me that resilience is not something you build in good conditions.

It is something that grows in the dark.

I have never forgotten that. Not in almost 30 years of sitting with children in their hardest moments. That knowledge earned at 24, in homes I still think about, is the foundation of everything I have done since.

When I moved into schools and school psychology, I brought all of it with me.

I have sat across from kids carrying trauma that most adults would collapse under. Children living in chaos, violence, and neglect, and they still show up. Every morning. They walk through those doors, find their seats, and try. Not all of them. Not every day. But enough. Enough to make you believe in something you cannot fully name.

Trauma and potential are not mutually exclusive. That is the thing that still amazes me after all these years.

A child can be an absolute wreck internally; dysregulated, scared, grieving something they do not even have language for yet, and simultaneously be reaching for something better. Reaching for the adult who will notice. Reaching for the future, they can almost see from where they are standing.

The younger kids, especially. They have not hardened yet, and they still want to please adults, especially their teachers. They still believe, in some deep unbroken part of themselves, that adults are safe and that effort is rewarded, and that tomorrow might be different from today.

I have spent years trying to be worthy of that belief.

Here is the honest part about how we talk about kids in schools. We are very good at finding what is wrong. We have built entire systems around the problems: classification, diagnosis, intervention, and documentation. Some of those do genuinely matter. The right support at the right time can genuinely change a child’s life. I have seen it happen and been part of the process.

But, somewhere in all the identifying and categorizing, we sometimes forget to ask what is also right.

I have worked with a boy who could not sit for forty minutes to save his life, but put something in front of him that he actually cared about, and he would not move for six hours. I have worked with a girl whose anxiety made school unbearable, who also happened to read people with a depth and accuracy that most adults never develop. I have worked with a boy who was labeled a behavior problem for two years before anyone figured out that he could not read and had been hiding it every single day because he was terrified, and nobody had thought to look.

The diagnosis tells you something is real. It does not tell you everything.

What I have seen over 30 years is this: the same diagnosis, in the hands of different adults, produces completely different outcomes. One child gets handed a label like a verdict. Another child gets handed the same label as information — here is how your brain works, here is what we can do with that information, and builds something nobody expected from there.

The difference is rarely the child.

It is the adult in the room, and what that adult decided to see first.

The hardest part of this work is something nobody in education says plainly enough.

For young children, almost nothing is within their control. They live where their parents live. Eat what their parents provide or don’t provide and wake up inside whatever emotional environment their family has created, and they carry all of it through the front door of the school building every single day.

Most parents are doing their best with what they have. I mean that sincerely. Many of the parents were raised inside the same chaos they are now unintentionally passing on. They love their kids, genuinely, completely, and at times still can’t give them what was never given to them. You cannot pour from an empty cup, and most of these parents are running on empty for a very long time. I have learned to hold both things at once. Compassion for the parent. Fierce, unwavering advocacy for the child.

But some parents are the source of the problem.

That is the sentence nobody in a school building says out loud. We talk about it and use careful language. We say things like “the home environment presents challenges”, or “the family system is under significant stress”.

What we mean is: this child is being harmed by the people who are supposed to protect them, and there is only so much a school building can do about that.

That particular helplessness, knowing something is not right, being limited in what you can change, is the thing that comes home with you. The things you think about at 2 A.M. The child you can’t stop worrying about, even when your “shift” is technically over.

That never gets easier. I don’t think it is supposed to.

A few years ago, I started getting phone calls and messages from former students.

Not a few. Many.

Even students I had worked with in elementary school. Specifically, the ones who had struggled, who had worried me, who I had stayed late for and lost sleep over. They were reaching out to tell me they were okay. They told me something I said or did mattered.

One young man sent me a message that I have read more times than I can count. He told me I was the first adult who made him feel like he was not broken. That I had seen something in him he could not see in himself. He wrote that spending lunch with me during his senior year was the highlight of his high school career.

I remembered him. Of course, I remembered him. How could I forget?

But I had no idea.

You rarely do. Then, something happened that shook me completely.

Students I had known in elementary school, the ones I had worried about, the ones whose files I had carried home in my mind, now have children of their own. Those children are students in my building. Sometimes their parents see me and stop to say hello and thank you.

Over twenty years of showing up in school.

That is what “thank you” looks like.

I am building Midlife Becoming because of everything I have learned over thirty years working with families and children.

The thing that makes a child resilient is exactly the thing that makes a midlife woman resilient. Someone who sees her. Someone who reflects what she cannot yet see in herself. Someone who says, “You are not broken, you are just in a hard season and hard seasons end”.

I have spent my entire career doing that work for children. Now I want to do it for women. Women who are 45, or 52, or 60, and standing in the middle of their own kind of chaos. The women who have been pouring themselves into everyone else for so long they have forgotten what they actually want. Women who are carrying grief and transition and reinvention all at the same time, and wondering if they are doing any of it right.

You are.

The fact that you are still here, still trying, and still reaching for something better? That is not small.

That is the whole thing.

Children taught me that.

Thirty years of watching them show up anyway.

— Barb

Leave a comment

Subscribe now

Let me tell you something about returning to graduate school 22 years later.

I was not afraid of the work.

I have been sitting with people in pain for more than three decades. I have navigated crisis, grief, trauma, addiction, and family collapse. I have delivered news nobody wanted to hear. I have held space for things most people never witness.

Walking into a counseling theory class? Fine.

Walking into Canvas for the first time? Absolutely not.

Canvas is the online learning platform modern universities use to assign and collect coursework. It is also, apparently, designed by people who have never encountered a 50-year-old woman returning to school after two decades away.

Where do I submit this?

Why is there a discussion board AND a module AND a folder for the same thing?

What is a live collaboration feature, and why does it need access to my microphone?

I called my daughter more times than I will admit. She was patient. Mostly.

The research papers had their own learning curve. Not the writing itself — I have been writing psychological evaluations and clinical reports for 25 years. I know how to construct an argument and build a case.

But APA format is a different kind of beast.

The citations. The hanging indents. The references. The way one misplaced punctuation mark can apparently collapse an entire bibliography. I once spent 45 minutes trying to figure out why my reference page looked wrong before realizing I had used a regular dash instead of an em dash. An em dash. I did not know what one was before graduate school. I have opinions about them now.

Here is what I did not expect: the clinical work felt effortless.

At our on-campus residencies, we practiced therapy techniques in front of professors and classmates — people who had no prior relationship with me and no reason to soften their feedback.

The feedback stopped me cold.

“You were made for this.”

“ You are effortless.”

“ You are going to be an incredible counselor.”

I have been doing some version of this work for 35 years. I know how to sit in a hard conversation without flinching. I know how to hold space. But hearing it reflected back by people with no stake in my ego? That landed differently than I expected.

I also did not expect to love being in class with people my daughter’s age.

I work at a high school. I have spent decades around young people. Their energy, their questions, the way they have not yet decided what is impossible — it kept me honest and sharp. They also helped me find the submit button more than once.

Leave a comment

Here is what the experience itself taught me, separate from the coursework and theory:

You do not lose what you have built.

Twenty-two years of living, working, surviving, and becoming does not disappear when you walk back into a classroom. It walks in with you. It shows up in every answer you give. It steadies you in a practice session when someone half your age is shaking.

The technology was humbling.

The scheduling was complicated.

The em dashes were genuinely unnecessary.

But the work itself? The work felt like coming home.

If you have been thinking about going back to school, a career pivot, to something you set down because life got loud — I want you to hear this clearly.

You are not starting over.

You are starting from experience.

That is not a small distinction.

It is everything.

— Barb

Something brought you here.

Maybe it was a Note that stopped you mid-scroll. Maybe someone shared something, and you thought — that’s exactly me. Maybe you’ve just been quietly feeling the pull toward something more, and you finally decided to follow it.

Whatever brought you- I am glad you’re here.

I’m Barb. School psychologist for 25 years. Graduate student at William & Mary studying Clinical Mental Health Counseling. Jersey Shore girl. Wife to Bob. Mom to Lily and Michael. Dog mom to Nash.

Also, a woman who spent most of her life taking care of everyone else before she finally decided to take care of herself.

I started Midlife Becoming because I needed it to exist. I kept looking for a space where midlife women could tell the truth about grief, about becoming, and the exhaustion of performing life that doesn’t fit anymore. I couldn’t find exactly what I was looking for.

So, I built it.

Personal essays — honest, specific, literary. About my mother. About grief. About the empty nest, about mental health and wellness. About what it means to keep becoming when everyone expects you to have it figured out by now.

Weekly letters — straight to your inbox. Real. Warm. Written for the woman in the middle of her own becoming.

Daily Notes — glimpses into this life I’m building. The ocean. The dog. The sunrise. The thoughts that arrive with coffee and don’t leave until I write them down.

A community — women who are done waiting. From New Jersey, Australia, South Africa, everywhere in between. Women who found each other here and said me too.

Start with these:

📖 I’m Just a girl from New York — origin story. Who I am and everything that made me.

📖 I Didn’t Expect Any of This — What happened when I showed up scared and told the truth in public anyway.

Before you go…

Take the quiz. Eight questions. Two minutes, it tells you exactly where you are in your becoming journey and what you need next. Find it at the link in my bio.

If these words resonate, subscribe. It’s free. It goes straight to your inbox. And I will always tell you the truth.

Welcome to Midlife Becoming.

You’re not done yet. 🌊

—Barb

Up early in the morning before anyone in the house. Coffee is still hot. She’s not scrolling. She’s working on a newsletter, an Instagram community, and a course she’s been building out for three months. Maybe it started with one post she almost didn’t publish. Something honest and a little raw. And somehow it landed, and women she’d never met started writing to say, “ Me too, finally, where have you been?”.

No publicist. No investors. No corner office.

Just a point of view, a platform, and more lived experience than any algorithm knows what to do with.

She is everywhere right now, and the business press is barely covering it.

Midlife women in their 40s, 50s, 60s are becoming one of the most significant forces in the digital economy. Not by pitching to investors or disrupting tech. By building communities so genuinely connected that they’re generating real income from platforms most people still don’t take seriously.

The numbers back this up, even if nobody’s leading with them.

The global creator economy is worth over $190 billion and growing at 22% a year. Goldman Sachs and several creator economy research firms project it’ll cross $500 billion by 2030. Women make up 51% of all content creators worldwide, a quiet demographic majority, and 78% of the creators who’ve actually converted their audience into income are women. They are not influencers or teenagers. They are women building businesses.

Gusto’s 2024 New Business Formation Report found that women launched 49% of all new businesses last year. That’s a 69% increase from 2019 and a five-year high. Multiple research bodies have called women over 50 they are the fastest-growing group of entrepreneurs in the world.

The fastest growing. Because of their age, not despite it.

The AARP looked at why women over 50 were starting things and found something that stuck with me. Their motivations were different from those of younger founders. Over a quarter had always wanted to build something but hadn’t. Nearly 20% were finally chasing something they’d shelved for years. Seventy percent said flexibility was the main draw and not as a fallback. They are taking back their time as a conscious choice.

Researchers who study this stage of life have a term for what happens cognitively around midlife “sage clarity.” It’s the specific kind of knowing that comes from having lived enough to understand what actually matters and what doesn’t. These women aren’t figuring themselves out. They’re done with that part. They know their audience because they are their audience. They’ve spent decades noticing what was missing from the conversation. Now they’re the ones filling it.

A peer-reviewed study in the journal Technovation described digital platforms as “scaffolding for liminality”, structures that hold people up while they’re moving through major transitions, letting them build income and identity at the same time. Instagram and Substack, offer something the traditional economy kept gatekeeping: direct access to an audience. Not an editor deciding you’re not relevant enough. No HR department telling you you’re overqualified. Just you, your voice, and whoever needs to hear it.

On Substack, the platform now has over 50 million active subscriptions. More than 50,000 publications are generating income. The top 10 authors are pulling in $40 million a year combined. Thirty-two million new subscribers joined in just three months of 2025 — which means discovery is moving fast, and writers who show up consistently are finding readers they couldn’t have reached before.

The part that’s telling: 63% of the top-tier Substacks, the ones with the highest paid subscriber counts, are written by men. Even on a platform built to level the field, the most visible spotlight still goes in one direction.

But underneath that top tier, women are building. Steadily, in the spaces that prestige media have been ignoring forever. Midlife wellness and identity, Grief after loss, and Confidence after 50. Body image in a culture that stops seeing you. The interior life of women, figuring out what comes next. These aren’t small topics. They’re the conversations millions of women are hungry to have with someone who actually gets it — and they’ll pay for access to the writer who shows up every week and delivers.

Instagram tells the same story. Women engage at higher rates than men and are more likely to make purchasing decisions based on what they see there. But more than that, women aren’t building followings. They’re building communities. There’s a genuine difference. A following is passive. A community shows up, responds, shares, and stays.

The research on online social capital, the trust and belonging that form inside a well-tended digital space, is clear that these things convert. Loyal communities become paying subscribers. Subscribers become advocates. Advocates become the kind of word-of-mouth that no ad spend can replicate.

Women are building this kind of community differently. More honestly. There is more real two-way exchange. It reads as vulnerability, but it functions as a strategy.

The monetization paths have also multiplied, including paid subscriptions, digital guides, online courses, brand deals with companies, and finally recognizing that midlife women control a massive share of consumer spending, consulting and coaching built on decades of professional expertise repackaged for people who are ready to pay for it directly.

And most of this is happening without any institutional backing. Gusto found that women are far less likely than men to use venture capital or government loans to fund their ventures. Women are bootstrapping, using savings, early subscription revenue, and the slow compounding of a community that grows because the content is good. A Boston Consulting Group study found that women-led startups generate about 10% more revenue over five years than those led by men, with dramatically less funding to start. Less money in. More value out. Built on relationships instead of runways.

I’ll be straight with you — I’m one of these women.

I am not at the scale I’m describing…Not yet. I launched @themidlifebecoming in early 2025 because I felt something shift that I couldn’t quite name, and later found confirmed in data: midlife clarifies things. What matters becomes obvious, and the things you’ve always wanted to say start feeling more urgent than whatever reasons you had for keeping them in.

I live at the Jersey Shore. Wildwood. There’s a certain kind of no-nonsense that gets wired into you when you come from a place like that; you can usually tell who’s performing and who’s just telling you the truth. What I found when I started building online was a whole world of women just telling the truth. Writing honestly and creating spaces where other women could breathe.

I found a community before I’d fully built one. That changed everything about how I understood what I was doing.

This isn’t a trend. It’s not a moment that’s going to pass. It’s a real shift in who gets to build, who gets to be heard, and what kind of expertise the world is finally willing to pay for.

If you’re a midlife woman who’s been circling something, a newsletter, an account, a community built around the thing you know better than almost anyone. The data says you’re not too late. You’re exactly on time.

If you’ve been watching women like this build something in the edges of your feed, in the newsletters you open every single week without fail, in the accounts that make you feel a little less like you’re doing this alone, pay attention to what they’re actually doing.

They’re building empires.

They just don’t make a lot of noise about it. Yet.

Sources: Gusto 2024 New Business Formation Report; Goldman Sachs Creator Economy Research; AARP Women Entrepreneurs 50+ Study (2023); Backlinko Substack Statistics 2025; Boston Consulting Group Women Entrepreneurs Revenue Study; Kelly & McAdam, “Scaffolding Liminality,” Technovation (2022); peer-reviewed gerontology research on women at midlife and the global longevity economy.

I’ve been sitting with something all week, and I couldn’t wait until May 1st to share it. It started as a thought about the calendar and turned into something that felt bigger than that. I hope it lands for you the way it landed for me.

There’s something about May.

It arrives without apology. After the grey of winter and the false starts of early spring, May just shows up. Full color. Full sun.

Completely unashamed of how good it is.

I’ve been thinking about that.

How many of us have spent years arriving quietly. Apologizing for taking up space.

Shrinking ourselves into something more manageable. More palatable. Less.

May doesn’t do that.

And this year I’ve decided I’m taking notes.

Because this month — May — is also a verb. A permission. A tiny radical act hiding inside the calendar.

You MAY take up space.

You MAY change your mind.

You MAY start before you’re ready,

You May stop explaining yourself.

You MAY want more.

You May be exactly enough right now.

You MAY finally become her.

Midlife has a way of making women feel like they’ve missed something. Like the window closed while they were busy keeping everyone else’s windows open.

It didn’t.

May is proof. Every single year this month

comes back. Bigger. Brighter. More alive than the year before.

So are you.

Happy May. This one’s yours.

Barb

Read through all four if you’d like. But I think you’ll know which one is yours.

Mostly A’s - You’re Still Standing

You are in the thick of it right now.

Something shifted — a loss, a transition, a life that looks different from what you planned - and you’re still finding your footing. Some days just getting through is genuinely the win. And that is okay. That counts.

You don’t need a five-year plan right now. You need permission to be exactly where you are without apologizing for it.

What you need most: Rest without guilt. Gentleness with yourself. The reminder that standing is its own form of strength.

You’re not behind. You’re still here. That matters more than you know.

Mostly B’s — You’re Still Searching

You feel it. That pull toward something more, something different - something that’s yours.

You can’t quite name it yet, and that’s what’s so frustrating. You know the life you’ve been living isn’t the whole story. You know there’s another chapter. You just haven’t found the first line yet.

What you need most: Permission to explore without having the answer. Space to ask the questions out loud. Someone to tell you the not-knowing is actually the beginning.

The searching is not wasted time. It’s how becoming starts.

Mostly C’s — You’re Already Building

You’re in motion. You have ideas, energy, maybe even a plan — and you’re doing the work of putting something real together even when it’s scary.

Some days it flows. Some days, you wonder if any of it will matter. You keep going anyway. That’s not small. That’s everything.

What you need most: Structure, community, and someone to remind you that what you’re building is worth the effort, even before you can see the whole picture.

You started. That’s the hardest part. Keep going.

Mostly D’s You’re Becoming

You’re in it. Fully, completely, sometimes overwhelmingly in it.

The becoming is happening in real time, and you can feel it — in the way you talk about your life, in the things you’re no longer willing to settle for, in the version of yourself that keeps showing up bigger and braver than the one before.

What you need most: Community with women who get it. Fuel for the journey. The reminder that this energy - this aliveness - is yours to keep.

You are not too much. You are finally enough.

Wherever you are - Still Standing, Still Searching, Already Building, or fully Becoming - you’re in the right place.

This is what Midlife Becoming is built for.

Pull up a chair.

If you’re not already subscribed, join us below. New essays, Notes, and honest conversation about this season of life — delivered straight to your inbox.

With love from the Jersey Shore,

Barb

Subscribe now

I entered this space scared.

The kind that makes your hands shake a little as you hit publish. Then you put your phone face down and walk away because you cannot bear to watch what happens next. I spent time writing papers in two graduate programs, twenty-five years of applying clinical language to other people’s pain, and an entire lifetime knowing that writing was my gift — and still, when it came to this, I felt exposed in a way I had not anticipated. Naked, almost like I had walked into a room and said, this is who I actually am and then stood there waiting to see what happened next.

What happened next completely surprised me.

Women started finding me. They left comments that cracked something open in my chest. Restacking words, I had almost talked myself out of posting. They wrote back to say, me too which made me feel like I was not the only one. This is, I think, the most anyone can hope for when they decide to tell the truth in public.

Over 50 of you are here now. Fifty women who said yes; I want to read what she has to say. I have been sitting with that number quietly all week, genuinely overwhelmed by it, genuinely grateful in a way. Thank you — From the bottom of my heart.

This platform is different from the others, I felt it immediately. There is substance here instead of surface. What lies beneath is what matters, not what looks good on a highlight reel. I didn’t realize how hungry I was for that until I found it.

I want you to know who you are reading.

I am a mom. Just a girl from New York who found her home at the Jersey Shore. I am a wife, a woman trying her best every single day with a genuine desire to connect with other women and help them feel less alone. I am not a guru. I am not a brand. I am akin to a simmering pot on the stove — that is the only way I know how to describe what is happening inside me right now — this energy and excitement for life that is bubbling up and wanting to spill over the sides, and I am honestly just trying to keep up with it.

I think it started with the sunsets.

Every evening I walk our dog Nash down to the end of our street, where the bay opens up, and I watch the sun go down. Nash is our golden doodle. He is six years old, adopted in the middle of Covid when the world had gone quiet, and we needed something warm and alive in our home. He has been with us through everything since. The hard days and the beautiful ones, the losses and the celebrations, every ordinary day. He doesn’t know any of that, of course. He just knows the walk, and the smells, and the way the light changes at the end of the street. Honestly, he has taught me more about being present than most things I have read or studied. My husband teases me about the sunsets — it’s the same thing every day, Barb. And every evening I think: it is never the same thing. Not once. Different colors, different light, different feeling in the air, different version of me standing there watching it. It is the end of another day in this chapter of my life. Sad and inspiring at the same time, a brief moment that is somehow also everything.

The mornings walking the beach as the glow from the sun starts to rise up from the water. There is that particular stillness before the world gets loud again. I know that only God could be the creator of something that beautiful. I think about what it means to bring even a fraction of that light into the interactions of an ordinary day; that is precisely what I am trying to do here.

That is what I keep coming back to: Connection, real connection, not the performative kind, actually seeing people and making space for them. The cashier at the McDonald’s drive-through window who hands me my coffee every morning and just needs someone to look her in the eye and mean it when they say good morning. The middle schoolers I work with every day, kids who are struggling to put words to what they’re feeling, who are acting out because they don’t yet have the language for their pain. They need one adult in the building to sit with them and say: I see you and you have potential. We are going to get through this together. I show up for them every single day, and honestly, they give back more than they will ever know. I want to be a positive force, not in a big way but quietly and consistently. I want to show up, pay attention, and truly care for those around me.

Then there is my circle. The small group of women I hold close, my people, my constants, the ones who have been there through every twist and turn without flinching. Women who are doing extraordinary things in their own midlife; going back for college degrees in their fifties, taking on major career shifts, showing up for their lives with a courage that takes my breath away sometimes. We have a group chat that keeps me going; it is not always profound. Sometimes it is just a funny meme or a string of laughing emojis or a quick “you got this, girl” before someone heads into a hard week. But it is everything. It is the kind of friendship that holds you up without making a big deal of it, and I do not take a single day of it for granted.

And then there are my kids. My daughter is out there in the world doing great things. She is showing me what it looks like to move through life with a grace, intention, and fearlessness that I am still learning at twice her age. She does not even know she is teaching me. My son is becoming a young man right before my eyes, and he is opening up slowly and steadily. He is like a flower bud that is just beginning to understand what he is capable of. The bones are there, and I can see them clearly, even when he cannot yet. I am so proud of both of them that I don’t have words for it — just this feeling in my chest like my heart is too big for the space it is supposed to fit in.

This is what I am made of. This is what I am writing from.

The goal is connection. To the earth, to the people we love, to the version of ourselves we are still becoming. Simply taking notice of the things that make life worth living. The flower beginning to bud on the branch, the breeze on your face. The smell of the salt air. All of the small things that make a life worth living. someday, not eventually, but right now, today, in the middle of everything.

That is what I am building here. A place to notice. A place to tell the truth. A place where midlife is not something to survive but something to finally, fully inhabit.

I am so glad you are here for it.

With love from the Jersey Shore,

Barb

A question to sit with this week:

What is your version of the sunset at the end of the street — the small, ordinary thing that fills you up if you let it? And when did you last let it?

midlifebecoming.substack.com · @themidlifebecoming

by Barb

The last time I saw my mother she was in her nursing home room, and I remember being so grateful just to be there — because for months during Covid I had not been allowed in at all, separated from her by a pandemic and a locked door and a helplessness I had no language for. We had just gotten a short month and a half together again before she left us. It was not enough time. It never would have been enough time. But I held her hand as she took her last breath, her breathing labored and heavy with fluid, and her face was so peaceful — ready, I thought. She was ready to meet Jesus, and I knew it, and I felt, underneath all the grief, a deep and quiet peace settling over me in that room.

Faith has always lived deep in my soul — not loudly, not rigidly, but quietly and persistently, the way the truest things tend to live in us. My parents were God-fearing Catholics who raised us with a belief that there was something bigger than ourselves holding everything together, and even as I have grown into my own relationship with God— attending Mass but not perfectly, believing deeply but not always conventionally —that faith has never left me. On my darkest days, it has been the only thing that carried me. Holding my mother’s hand in that nursing home room, I felt it more clearly than I ever had. She was at peace. She was held. And so, somehow, was I. She was such a good mother. I was grateful for every single moment we had ever shared, right back to the earliest ones I can remember — her moving around her kitchen in her housecoat, always cooking, always caring, showing us her love the only way she knew how, through food and presence and showing up every single day without fail. She was a caretaker to her core. She gave everything she had to her family and maybe never fully found herself outside of that role, and I have thought about that many times over the years— wondered if watching her pour herself out so completely was part of what planted in me such a fierce need to also find and claim myself.

But to understand who I am today, you have to start with my father, because he is the foundation of everything.

My dad was the son of Italian immigrants, the only boy, and he left school somewhere around seventh or eighth grade because sitting still in a classroom was never where his gifts lived. His gifts lived in his hands — big, rough hands, calloused from decades of hard work, from driving an eighteen-wheeler for Volkswagen across the country, from taking apart engines he had never seen before and putting them back together without a manual, from fixing whatever broke in our home without ever calling anyone for help. He joined the Navy when he was young. He grew plants that thrived like they were reaching specifically toward him. He loved his coffee — strong and hot, every single morning —and I think about that every time I pour my own cup because I am so much his daughter in that way and in so many others. He had a loud voice, a strong presence, a big opinion about most things — but underneath all of that, underneath the big Italian man with the big personality, was the gentlest heart I have ever known.

He loved me like I was the greatest thing on earth, and I believed him, because that is what real love does — it makes you believe it.

I was his youngest, his daddy’s little girl, and on Saturday mornings we would get in the car together and just go — to get breakfast, to run errands, to visit relatives, nowhere important — and I was always happy just to be next to him. It did not matter where we were going. It never mattered. He made me feel seen and capable and completely cherished, and I carried that feeling like a lantern into every dark season that followed. He had his first heart attack when I was eight or nine years old, a quadruple bypass that scared us all, and then a valve replacement years later, and then multiple myeloma found him when I was already grown and living at the Shore and building my own life. I lost him anyway — the way we always lose the people we love most, never quite prepared even when we have had years of warning. He took a piece of my heart with him that I have stopped trying to recover, because it was never mine to keep. It belonged to him.

I have leaned on my faith in those moments the way you lean on a wall when your legs stop working — not dramatically, not with any particular words, just with the quiet trust that he is still somewhere close, still proud, and that the love between us does not actually end.

Dad — thank you. I am everything I am today because of the love you gave me without condition or limit, every single day of my life. I could never have become who I am without you believing in me first.

I am the youngest of four — two boys and two girls — and we grew up in New York without a lot of money but with each other, and I always believed that was more than enough. I had a fire in me from the very beginning. I skipped a grade. School came easily and naturally — I was academically gifted in a way that felt like a quiet superpower, and writing especially was always my gift, the place where everything I was thinking and feeling could come out shaped and true. I started working at twelve, tutoring younger students, and I never really stopped after that — a supermarket, drug and alcohol counseling, child protective services, graduate school, and eventually a career as a school psychologist that has now spanned twenty-five years and taught me more about human beings and human pain and human resilience than any textbook ever could. I built everything one deliberate step at a time, fiercely independent, never wanting to ask for help, always certain I could figure it out on my own. That independence served me in a hundred ways and cost me in a hundred others, and I am still learning to tell the difference.

And then there was my sister.

She was the best aunt when she was herself — at my house every weekend when my children were small, filling every room with warmth, loving on my babies with everything she had. She just wanted to be loved. That was the truest and most heartbreaking thing about her — she had so much love to give and she just needed someone to give it back to her in a way that held. When she got cancer she fought hard, went through radiation and chemotherapy, lost her hair, kept going — but the illness pushed her toward things she had already been struggling with, and she slipped into addiction and mental illness in ways I watched from three hours away with two young children and a full-time career and a heart that was breaking quietly every single day.

The hardest part of all of it — the part that still visits me in quiet moments — is that I was a psychologist. I had the education, the clinical language, the professional framework for exactly what she was going through. I had spent my entire career sitting with families in crisis and helping them find a way through. And I could not save my own sister. That helplessness has never fully left me, and neither has the guilt, and I have had to learn —slowly and imperfectly and with a great deal of grace from my faith — to forgive myself for being only human, even when I desperately wished I could have been more.

To my sister — I am so sorry. You were such a good sister and you deserved so much more than what life gave you. I have never stopped loving you, and I never will.

I tell you all of this because I want you to know exactly who you are reading. I am not a curated highlight reel or a polished brand. I am a woman with wounds and scars and losses that shaped her in ways she is still discovering — a girl from New York who pushed through at every turn not because it was easy but because stopping was never in her nature.

I have been married to my husband Bob for almost twenty-five years, since I was barely twenty years old and met him at his family’s restaurant in Wildwood, New Jersey, where I have lived and loved the Jersey Shore ever since. He is quiet where I am loud, steady where I am restless, loyal in a way that has never once wavered through every idea and phase and transformation I have brought into our life together. He is my rock in the truest sense of that word, and I thank God for him regularly.

We raised two children together, and I poured myself into their lives completely — not with money, because money was never the thing we had in abundance, but with love and experiences and presence and the absolute bone-deep certainty that they were cherished. My children attended Catholic school, rooted in the same faith their grandparents planted in me, and I wanted that for them — that sense of something larger than themselves to hold onto when life gets hard, because life always gets hard eventually. I did all of it while my mother was living with us in her final years, declining slowly in the same house where my children were growing up and learning what family looks like, all of those seasons layering over each other the way life tends to do when it has a great deal to teach you at once.

After she was gone, I looked honestly at where I was heading, and I knew something had to change. I had struggled with my weight since my mid-twenties — always knowing I was smart and capable and worthy while never quite feeling at home in my own body, that particular disconnect quietly accompanying everything else I carried. So I made a decision. I had gastric sleeve surgery, and I lost over one hundred pounds. I built a body I am genuinely proud of, and the truest thing I can tell you about all of it is simply this — this is my new body, but it is me. It is who I was always meant to be, because the confidence was inside me the whole time. I just had not known it yet. It took losing my mother and sitting with that loss honestly and deciding that my world was not going to get smaller just because hers had — it took all of that to finally let her out.

Writing was always my gift, and I started this Substack and my Instagram account because I finally had something to say, and I had stopped waiting for the perfect moment to say it. One quiet afternoon a switch just clicked, and I thought — I am doing this — and I did, which is honestly how most of the important decisions of my life have happened. Not perfectly planned. Not perfectly timed. Just a moment of clarity and the willingness to act on it before the fear could talk me out of it.

I want women to know that it is not too late. That you can begin your becoming at any phase of life, from any starting point, carrying whatever you have been carrying. That the hard things — the losses, the regrets, the seasons that nearly broke you — do not have to be the end of your story. They can be, if you let them, the beginning of the most honest and fully alive version of it.

My faith tells me that we are not here by accident. That our stories are not random. That the losses and the scars and the hard seasons are not punishments but invitations — to grow deeper, to love better, to become more fully who we were created to be. I am not a perfect Catholic. I will tell you that honestly right now. But I am a deeply spiritual woman who believes in Jesus and who believes that God has had a hand in every turn of this story— including this one. Including you finding your way here today.

I have a beautiful life. A cozy home at the Shore, a family I love with everything I have, a faith that has carried me through every dark season I have ever walked through, a career behind me I am proud of, and one ahead that genuinely excites me. I do not take a single day for granted. I carry my father’s belief in me and my sister’s memory and my mother’s housecoat and her cooking and Bob’s steady love and my children’s whole futures ahead of them like open water, and I am grateful — deeply, daily, actively grateful — for every single piece of it.

You do not need a lot of money to build something real and beautiful. You need love and determination and the willingness to keep going even when the path is not clear, even when you are grieving, even when you are doing the best you can with what you have.

You need someone who believes in you completely — and if you do not have that yet, I am here to be that for you until you find it in yourself. All good things are possible for you. I believe that with every scar and every loss and every hard-won beautiful imperfect thing I have ever built.

Welcome to The Midlife Becoming.

I am so glad you found your way here.

— Barb

If this resonated with you please subscribe so you don’t miss what comes next. The grief and transformation series begins soon.

The Midlife Becoming · midlifebecoming.substack.com · Instagram: @themidlifebecoming

For women who aren’t done becoming.